Political Duties And Moral Obligations - 1518 Words

Essay One I Abbie Humphreys declare that I have neither received nor given any unauthorized assistance on this assignment. It’s a difficult thing to decide whether one’s moral obligation should take precedence over civil duty, or vice versa. As both of these aspects of life are vital to the smooth running of society, though it can be said that there are moral â€Å"grey areas† where we can believe that we are more right and more just than the law. In these readings our main characters all believed they were above the law, and that their moral obligations were more important from a justice viewpoint leading them to trouble from the law. This does not mean that political duties are always at odds with moral obligations, in a sense political duties to comply with our own moral obligations with the exception of some grey areas. In this paper I will argue that political duties and moral obligations do comply with each other, while our civil duty of being law abiding citizens s hould come first. In Antigone, she decides to go against the new law that King Creon declares against the burial of the traitor, Polyneices. Polyneices is Antigone’s brother who attacked the city of Thebes with the Argive army causing the war, Eteocles his brother kills him and is also killed in the process, the King gives Eteocles a hero’s burial but denies an appropriate burial for Polyneices. Antigone decides to do what she believes is morally just over what is lawfully right and gives Polyneices aShow MoreRelatedTypes of Utilitarianism1211 Words   |  5 Pagesutilitarian approach to moral obligation is different; its proponents are John Stuart Mill, Jeremy Bentham. There are two types of utilitarianism: The act utilitarianism and the rule utilitarianism. But Critics of utilitarianism have claimed that the moral theory is capable of accounting for the stringency of certain kinds of moral obligation such as promissory obligations. However, Sartorius (1969) asserts that act utilitarianism claims that features of moral obligation are based upon retrospectiveRead MoreWhy Political Obligation Can Not Be Grounded?1187 Words   |  5 Pagesâ€Å"Political Obligation Cannot be grounded in Benefits since Most Citizens Never Ask to Receive Such Benefits† – Discuss To have political obligation is to have a duty to obey the laws of one’s country or state. The benefits that may result in political obligations can include security, welfare and infrastructure. The benefit theory for obligation has many criticisms besides the idea that â€Å"most citizens never ask for them† and I am going evaluate this theory alongside what I argue to be the reasonRead MoreShould Laws Always Be Obeyed?981 Words   |  4 PagesShould laws always be obeyed? I regard the law as standing under legally enforceable duties to one another. In all fields of law, the emphasis is ever on duty, be it agreed duty, as in a contract, or imposed duty, as in a tort or a crime. Legal obligations upheld by the social contract may limit people’s liberty but do so only in ways necessary to yield benefits for all. The ‘rule of law’ governs the conducts between people and arguably serves the greater interests of all participants in a legalRead MoreThe Ethics Of Non Voluntary Active Euthanasia1050 Words   |  5 Pagesdeontology suggest duty and obligation. A medical professional in such situations have an obligation to fulfill the patient s wishes. The nature of their obligation does not sway based on what they personally think. Patients with dementia have some moments of clarity, but because their brains are still deteriorating, non- voluntary active euthanasia should still be permissible under these conditions. In the theory of deontology, it is defined as â€Å"the focus on the duties and obligations one has in carryingRead MoreJean Jacques Rousseau s Principle Of Governing1391 Words   |  6 Pagesrights of its population. In this system, education is a right, and duties include military service, obedience to the one party in charge of the continent, and the sense of civic responsibility means upholding the ideal of equality across the entire spectrum of society. This cross-examination will show that even in vastly differing landscapes of political economy and civil society, the principles of balance between civic rights, duties, and responsibilities follow measurably similar patterns. The basisRead MoreMoral Responsibility797 Words   |  4 Pages(A) of the core moral responsibility This is done by P. Pula Li (Peter Pratley)proposed. Pula Li believes that the same as the implementation of quality management, companies also accept the moral responsibility of the concrete. at the lowest level, the enterprise must take three responsibilities: (1) concern for consumers, such as the ability to meet the ease of use, product safety And other requirements; (2)concern for the environment; (3) interest on the minimum working conditions. Platts theseRead MoreWhistleblowing1148 Words   |  5 PagesWhile many of us can see the criminal and political ramifications of whistleblowing there is still one area that can often be seen as a more personal one†¦that of the ethical debate. As stated in Lars Lindblom’s article Dissolving the Moral Dilemma of Whistleblowing, â€Å"The ethical debate on whistleblowing concerns centrally the conflict between the right to political free speech and the duty of loyalty to the organization where one works.†2 The political philosophy of John Rawls that can be appliedRead MorePolitical Ideals And Ideology : Take Home Test 1991 Words   |  4 PagesKorede Kazeem 7707916 Political ideals and ideology Take home test 1 Do we have a political obligation to obey the law? We have a political obligation to obey the law in our society , this belief is backed up by the justifications of fairness, consent, utilitarianism, and morality, but the most compelling arguments found for the justification of why we should obey the law are consent, fairness and morality, Utilitarianism. Although there are many justifications for why we should obey theRead More Democracy and Political Obligation Essay4061 Words   |  17 PagesThe public life of political servants is characterized by other duties and obligations than private life. Conflicts can even arise between a persons public and private duties. The central point of this paper is to examine whether this difference of duties can be regarded as an effect of different forms of obligation. Can we speak of a particular form of political obligation in the same way in which Kant distinguishes between ethical and legal obligation, the former pertaining to intentions and theRead MoreHobbes And Locke s Political Legitim acy1530 Words   |  7 PagesIn defining political legitimacy, many theorists put forth a distinct set of values that frame their view on the authorities’ right to rule and citizen’s obligation to follow. Theorists such as Hobbes and Locke, both of their account on political legitimacy might look quite similar at first glance, because each theorized about the nature of mankind and the right political systems that would meet the needs of individuals. However, in Hobbes’ perspective, political authority does not pre-exist in individual’s